PrideArts’ ‘Constellations’ Is A Thought-Provoking Exploration Of Love And Possibility
With two alternating casts bringing different perspectives to the same story, PrideArts’ Constellations offers audiences a rare opportunity to experience Nick Payne’s exploration of love, choice, and parallel universes in two distinct ways.

In a theatre city like Chicago, you sometimes have the opportunity to see the same play performed by different companies, casts, and directors. Each interpretation can be compelling in its own way, expanding your appreciation for a piece you’ve already enjoyed. But it’s not often that you get the chance to see two different casts perform the same show during a single run at the same theater.
“In Nick Payne’s Evening Standard Award-winning Constellations, a quantum physicist and a beekeeper meet at a barbecue — and then meet again. Same two people. Infinite first dates. Across parallel universes, one tiny shift in tone or choice can mean the difference between a lifetime together and a heartbreaking goodbye.”
While Constellations has traditionally been performed by a man and a woman, PrideArts received special permission to stage the show with same-sex couples on alternating nights. Co-directed by Amber Mandley and Jay Españo, this Chicago premiere stars Shannon Bachelder and Hannah Green in one cast, and Jay Españo and Skyler Tipton in the other. Audiences now have the unusual opportunity to experience the same story through two different pairings.

The stage is sparsely set but intriguing. Hundreds of teardrop-shaped glass pieces hang from the ceiling, while the floor is covered in honeycomb-shaped patterns. Three groupings of pillars rise from the floor, providing places for the actors to sit and retrieve small props.
At several points, brown and green honeycomb-shaped lighting fills in the floor patterns, while multicolored waves of cosmic-looking light wash over the middle of the stage. Both add to the sense that we’re watching something that exists across multiple possibilities and dimensions.
The story is nonlinear and fascinating. Two people meet and develop a relationship, but you’re never quite sure where in time you are. Sometimes you watch an interaction unfold in the storyline from beginning to end – other times, you’re dropped into a scene where the characters clearly have history, only to piece together the missing details later.

As you might expect in a story about parallel universes, Marianne and Rona are often the same people at different stages of their lives, facing different challenges or responding to one another in different ways. They revisit many of the same interactions, often with nearly identical dialogue, but the outcomes change. You get to see how one small shift in a choice or reaction can lead to an entirely different result.
The performance I attended featured the female cast, with Shannon Bachelder as Marianne and Hannah Green as Rona. Their dynamic clicked even when their characters didn’t. Green’s Rona is intense, comedic, and turbulent, while Bachelder brings a more subtly emotional, anchoring presence to Marianne. Loving someone isn’t always easy, and the chemistry between the two performers captures both a shared history and the difficulties of two different people desperately trying to get on the same page.
This special engagement offers a chance to see an out-of-this-world play interpreted in two different ways. Choose the performance that works best for your schedule, and when you leave the theater, you’ll receive a half-off coupon to return and see the other cast. It’s not often you get such a good reason to see the same show twice, and this is one worth taking advantage of.
Constellations runs for approximately 80 minutes with no intermission. This show is appropriate for anyone ages 13 and up.
Constellations is playing at the Hoover-Leppen Theatre at Center on Halsted through 12/13/2026. Tickets can be purchased through the PrideArts website. Center on Halsted is located at 3656 N Halsted St in Chicago.
